The bookshelves have become overgrown, your notes nothing anyone would recognize as an organized pattern. So many things that make no sense, or only make sense to you.
I think this applicable to the whole book. Looking through a magnifying glass, nothing really happens in this book. A lot of walking and pondering and musing.
The biologist muses, as she contemplates a tide pool starfish in Annihilation, “the longer I stared at it, the less comprehensible the creature became. The more it became something alien to me, the more I had a sense that I knew nothing at all.” Faced with an encounter with the terrifyingly real, her erstwhile script is wrenched away, along with a clear sense of who she is. Because what is really there, like Area X, is too complex in its workings, exists on too many scales, is too big and too small for us to ever fully comprehend. We defend ourselves against that revelation for our own self-protection. Literally. The more one learns about the workings of natural systems, the more our everyday notions of selfhood and humanity crumble away. It’s difficult to maintain the fiction of separation between human and nature, for instance, once you find out that there are billions of microorganisms in the human body, discover that we are not singular creatures but functioning ecosystems made of things that are not human but are us, all the same.
I agree – Area X has become too massive that not even the Author understands it anymore or the logic by which it operates.
Other things operate on and around us that are too big for us to grasp, like the climate emergency, and Acceptance crackles with that particular context. It grapples with the problem of how to engage with the hyperobject of climate breakdown, and one reading of Area X is as a displaced, reworked, urgent version of it; both Area X and the climate crisis have the capacity to burn through everything, anywhere in a text, anywhere in a life, with unbidden, sudden, terrible brightness.
I don’t think I could have phrased it this well – that Area X is a hyperobject of climate breakdown. it’s more like an entity with no brain but still expanding and analyzing things at a base level, imitating life as it sees it.
Ooff, the book was weird. Written from multiple POVs, including the cloned biologist, the investigator from the book before (Control), Grace and then The Director (her story bringing up how perhaps AreaX started off and how it came to be around a lighthouse). The writing is again, too convoluted to follow for prolonged period of time (it has put me to sleep many a night). Everyone just wallows.
Eventually, you recognize that you have lost the ability to speak. But you are still there, muffled and distant, as if you’re a kid lying on a blanket on this very beach, with a hat over your eyes. Lulled into drowsiness by the constant surging sound of the water and the sea breezes, balancing the heat that ripples over you, spreads through your limbs. The wind against your hair is a sensation as remote as the ruffling of weeds sprouting from a head-shaped rock.
We also get the story from the Lighthouse Keeper’s POV and for some reason, his voice is identical to The Director’s and it’s so hard to tell them apart without the headings.
At his feet lay bramble and the thick gray of thistles that would bloom purple in the spring and summer. To his right, the ponds were dark with the muttering complaints of grebes and buffleheads. Blackbirds plunged the thin branches of trees down, exploded upward in panic at his passage, settled back into garrulous communities. The brisk, fresh salt smell to the air had an edge of flame: a burning smell from some nearby house or still-smoldering bonfire.
The clone, Ghost Bird, is also finding her own identity besides being a copy of a biologist, with her memories but without her wants and wishes.
“I’m not an answer,” she said. “I’m a question.” She might also be a message incarnate, a signal in the flesh, even if she hadn’t yet figured out what story she was supposed to tell.
I don’t think the Author knows either!
And then the lighthouse motif. The inner light, the shards… people still emanated light in their way, still shone across the miles as a warning, an invitation, or even just a static signal
Sometimes, too, other people gave you their light, and could seem to flicker, to be hardly visible at all, if no one took care of them. Because they’d given you too much and had nothing left for themselves.
Still, having decided to finally let the brightness take me, after holding out against it for so many years, I am giving it one more try.
And then the book goes on to be completely bleak – talking about humanity like the trash it produces, calling Area X almost like a solution- a reset to origin, a way for nature to reclaim its own back.
He was walking toward the lighthouse along the trail, but the moon was hemorrhaging blood into its silver circle, and he knew that terrible things must have happened to Earth for the moon to be dying, to be about to fall out of the heavens. The oceans were filled with graveyards of trash and every pollutant that had ever been loosed against the natural world. Wars for scant resources had left entire countries nothing but deserts of death and suffering. Disease had spread in its legions and life had begun to mutate into other forms, moaning and mewling in the filthy, burning remnants of once mighty cities, lit by roaring fires that crackled with the smoldering bones of strange, distorted cadavers.
Good visual – I like the metaphor about the moon hemorrhaging blood.. very red, very bad. Death and suffering and bleakness and a complete lack of a plot.
I wonder how much of this book was actually the writer’s own journal? Maybe he identified himself as the lighthouse keeper, trying to maintain something that was being damaged every day by the salty water, keeping his sermons private.
Writing, for me, is like trying to restart an engine that has rested for years, silent and rusting, in an empty lot—choked with water and dirt, infiltrated by ants and spiders and cockroaches. Vines and weeds shoved into it and sprouting out of it. A kind of coughing splutter, an eruption of leaves and dust, a voice that sounds a little like mine but is not the same as it was before; I use my actual voice rarely enough.
A great deal of time has passed since I placed words on paper, and for so long I felt no urge to do so again.
Almost like a creationist myth once over again:
There came an incandescent light. There came a star in motion, the sun plummeting to Earth. There fell from the heavens a huge burning torch, thick flames dripping out behind it. And this light, this star, shook the sky and the beach where he had walked a second ago under a clear blue sky. The scorched intensity of the sudden object hurtling down toward him battered his senses, sent him sprawling to his knees as he tried to run, and then dove face-first into the sand. He screamed as the rays, the sparks, sprayed out all around, and the core of the light hit somewhere in front of him, his teeth smashed in his mouth, his bones turned to powder. The reverberation lived within him as he tried to regain his footing, even as the impact conjured up an enormous tidal wave like a living creature, aimed at the beach. When it fell upon him the weight, the immensity, destroyed him once more and washed away anything he could have recognized, could have known. He gasped and thrashed and hurt, dug his tortured hands into the shocking cold sand. The sand had a different texture, and the tiny creatures living there were different. He didn’t want to look up, take in his surroundings, frightened that the landscape, too, might have changed, might be so different he would not recognize it.
The tidal waves faded. The burning lights receded.

The night was full of white rabbits streaking across the sky, instead of the stars, the moon—and Control knew that was wrong in some fevered part of his mind, some compartment holding out against the inquisitive brightness. Were they white rabbits or were they smudges of black motion rendered as photo negatives impeding his vision? Because he didn’t want to see what was there. Because the biologist had unlocked something inside of him, and he returned now sometimes to the phantasmagorical art in Whitby’s strange room in the Southern Reach, and then to his theory that to disappear into the border was to enter some purgatory where you would find every lost and forgotten thing: all of the rabbits herded across that invisible barrier, every beached destroyer and truck from the night Area X had been created. The missing in action from the expeditions. The thought a kind of annihilating abyss. Yet there was also the light blossoming from the place below the Crawler, detailed in the biologist’s journal account. Where led that light?
The present moments elongated, once past still ponds and into the final miles. She lived in the present by dint of blistered feet and chafed ankles and biting flies drawn to the sweat on her ears or forehead and the parched feeling in her throat despite drinking water from her canteen. The sun had decided to lodge itself behind her eyes and shine out so that the inside of her head felt burned. Every beautiful thing that lay ahead she knew she had seen at least once behind her. Eternity found in the repetition of Grace’s steps, her sometimes halting steps, and the constant way the light gripped the ground and sent its heat back up at her.
Also, Area X is supposed to be at the forefront of the story. In Annihilation, it was the main character, and the humans were essentially sacrificial lambs to the overarching mystery. They didn’t even have names to begin with! In books two and three, however, Area X is in the backseat while the human characters are put at the forefront. There’s nothing wrong with that provided that the human characters are good, and that we can relate to them on some level. However, none of the characters end up being anything more like whiny caricatures.


