Yes please.
The many lives of theoretical physicist Elsie Hannaway have finally caught up with her. By day, she’s an adjunct professor, toiling away at grading labs and teaching thermodynamics in the hopes of landing tenure. By other day, Elsie makes up for her non-existent paycheck by offering her services as a fake girlfriend, tapping into her expertly honed people pleasing skills to embody whichever version of herself the client needs.
Honestly, it’s a pretty sweet gig—until her carefully constructed Elsie-verse comes crashing down. Because Jack Smith, the annoyingly attractive and broody older brother of her favorite client, turns out to be the cold-hearted experimental physicist who ruined her mentor’s career and undermined the reputation of theorists everywhere. And that same Jack who now sits on the hiring committee at MIT, right between Elsie and her dream job.
Elsie is prepared for an all-out war of scholarly sabotage but…those long, penetrating looks? Not having to be anything other than her true self when she’s with him? Will falling into an experimentalist’s orbit finally tempt her to put her most guarded theories on love into practice?


Yep, yep, yep. I am reading a lot more romance novels recently while I’m trying to clear my backlog of books. Yes, I still haven’t finished Jeff Vandermeer’s Annihilation book 3.. It’s a slow read.
After watching the Love Hypothesis movie from Netflix, I was intrigued when I found out it was based on a book. Thankfully, my giant library already contained an Ali Hazelwood book I hadn’t read – Love Theoretically so I decided to start with this and then if it’s good and I like it, I’ll purchase the other book based on which the movie was based on.
Holy hell, I felt a stir I haven’t in a long while. Smart people falling in love. A good plot. Good puns (Oh, the puns!!) and a critical look at the life of a TA in university (and general life in Academia). The emails one would receive to ask for an extension. The dead family members. The double spacing questions. The occasional dick pick and drunken texts. The overachievers asking about grading 23h after submitting a report. YES. I know this. I lived this. It was spot on.
To know that I teach nine courses and commute between three different universities, translating into some five hundred students sending me pics of the weird rash on their crotch to get their absence excused. That I make so little money, it’s almost no money. That I have no long-term contract or benefits
The story is pretty good. I lie. It’s brilliant.
Easy peasy, photons squeezy.
I loved the main girl, Elsie. She’s whip smart and full of quips and references which make you smile. I love her and I’m definitely not into women. And in her job as a fake girlfriend (which btw is a thing if you follow Japanese and Korean Mangas), she meets Jack Smith, a handsome blonde boy, the brother of her date.
I used to think—no, I used to know that light-haired guys weren’t attractive. Middle school? Everyone went after Legolas, but I was an Aragorn girl. “Which Game of Thrones House Are You” BuzzFeed quiz? Never a Targaryen. I hate that I look at Jack Smith, with his good jaw and his good dimples and those good hands, and find him handsome
And it turns out Jack Smith is actually Jonathan Turner-Smith, her arch-nemesis, the man who, at 17, published a paper which ended up discrediting her mentor and person she looks up to and her profession – a physics theorist (a person who sits and thinks of equations for fun). Unfortunately for Elsie, she didn’t have enough time to be a full time theorist as her many jobs to keep her afloat are taking up all her time:
Teaching load: 100 percent. Despair load: incalculable.
I know that feeling.
So she decides to accept an invite to an interview and guess who’s on the panel! Same guy she despises. And after a few personal bumps, she really can’t stand him and he seems to gravitate towards her just to annoy her. I was laughing so hard when he got described in his normal environment (teaching at his tenured university position)
In theory, it’s a scene I know well. The few minutes leading up to the start of class: students enjoying the last few seconds with their phones, the instructor scrambling to pull up the PowerPoint against all IT odds (missing cables, incompatibility issues, never-ending Windows 10 updates). In practice, there are about twenty pairs of eyes in the room, and they’re all fixed on Jack with a mix of admiration, respect, and awe, like he’s the dominant turkey of the mating season.

Jack’s in the fourth row, paying me an uncomfortable amount of attention, writing something in a notebook. At best, he’s doodling cool S’s—at worst, drafting an online petition to dissuade MIT from hiring a diabetic slug who pilfers imported sodas and catfishes impressionable young men. He has something planned. I know it. He knows it. We both know it, and that’s why our gazes meet and hold so often. But I’ve practiced this talk so much, I could give it while getting my crotch waxed. Whatever you’re plotting, I’m ready for it,
Now things go a bit badly – she doesn’t get selected for the position but then she finds out it’s because the interview was a fake-out, they already had preselected the candidate they wanted to hire and she came with her own grants and research papers. Elsie is obviously disappointed and mad, but something else. She’s leaning into the person who got under her skin during the interviewing – Jack Smith. He’s not all that gruff and he’s obsessed with her! Wants to take care of her!
OMG – Ali Hazelwood knows what women really want. For someone to look after them and give them attention and love. (who knew?)
The romance part is top-notch.
The electron to my nucleus, constantly spinning around me in the most annoying of orbits. He’s so close I have to tilt my chin, and from this perspective it strikes me again how handsome he is.
He looks like an oak tree on steroids with a six-foot-eight wingspan. Is he even human?
AND THE SEX SCENES!
“I will give you anything I have—anything you want, if you let me go down on you right now.”
I lie back, enjoy the fullness, and try to decide in the mush that is my brain. “I’ve never done it,” I whisper, and Jack must find the situation unacceptable, because he drops to his knees in front of me and inhales deeply against the crease of my abdomen.
It takes exactly two swipes of his tongue to send me to outer space. One around my opening, where he’s stretching me too wide, and I think I’m going to die of embarrassment, of heat, of the liquid pressure that grows with each of his guttural groans. Then he moves up to my clit, and I know—I know—that nothing has ever felt like this in my life, that good things come sparingly, that I should try to make this last, but it’s over before it starts. My body seizes and snaps and bursts into a bubble of simple, pure, physical pleasure that feels too intense to weather alone. My fingers pull Jack’s hair too tight, dig in his scalp, and he keeps on eating at me, even when I’m coming down. His fingers stay deep inside, as if to give me something to contract around while I ride it out, and it’s perfect, this. It’s explosive, crashing, nuclear. Somewhere in the universe antimatter is being produced, and it’s all because of this.
Because of us.
“I think I’m dying,” I say the second I can breathe, completely serious. My heels are digging into his back, and wet noises rise up from where he’s still running his tongue over me.
“I think I want to do this every day,” he responds, kissing my pussy like he would my mouth. “Every day for the rest of my life.”

It’s beautiful, having him on top of me. He’s so wide and heavy, I’d have expected feeling constrained, unpleasantly held down, but there’s none of that. I wrap my arms around his neck, tip my chin up to kiss him, let him press me into the mattress and deliciously contain me.
“No one has felt like this in all of history,” he tells me, voice deep and shaky, and then he’s kissing me hard, his tongue licking inside my mouth, and after a few seconds of that I’m softer, I’m open, I’m lost, and it takes only two upward thrusts, one forceful and the other almost accidental. Then I’m taking him right to the hilt, feeling his sack flush against me, and it feels like something dreamt, something meant to be.
“Fuck,” he murmurs again, but I barely hear him. I focus on my own body, the way it’s stretched full. I feel Jack in the bones of my skull, in the tips of my toes, and everywhere in between. I thrum, flutter gently around him, and even though I’ve never been this close to anyone else, it’s still not enough

The morning light is blinding white, as painful as a million naked mole rats gnawing at my eyeball
Please, please go back to the sexy stuff. This was intense.
“I want you, Elsie. All the time. I think of you. All. The. Fucking. Time. I’m distracted. I’m shit at work. And my first instinct, the very first time I saw you, was to run away. Because I knew that if we’d start doing this, we would never stop. And that’s exactly how it is. There is no universe in which I’m going to let you go. I want to be with you, on you, every second of every day. I think—I dream of crazy things. I want you to marry me tomorrow so you can go on my health insurance. I want to lock you in my room for a couple of weeks. I want to buy groceries based on what you like. I want to play it cool, like I’m attracted to you and not obsessed out of my mind, but that’s not where I’m at. Not at all. And I need you to keep us in check. I need you to pace us, because wherever it is that we’re going . . . I’m here. I’m already right here.
Love that.
Sooo, what I didn’t cover was that the book definitely has some tropes: man with a traumatic past (check), evil step-mom (check), quirky relative helping out (check), man emotionally closed off until the right woman comes along (check) and a woman who is cool but also generic enough that the woman reader could easily identify themselves in Elsie’s position (check). What was a bit new was the intensity Jack goes after Elsie, his respect for the request for space, the fact that Elsie is also flawed in trying to please everyone – and thus not really revealing her true self or living an authentic life – and the desire from Jack to be with the authentic Elsie, thus encouraging her to speak out and speak up.
Loved that. OK, I think I’ll go put this book in my favourites section and I can’t wait to read Love Hypothesis.


